Pirelli Scorpion Winter 2 Tests & Review

Pirelli Scorpion Winter 2 photo, test, review, ratings

Pirelli Scorpion Winter 2 is a High-Performance winter tire with a directional tread pattern designed for SUVs.

The tire replaced the Pirelli Scorpion Winter.

4.4

Average
place

3

Best
place

6

Worst
place

5

times
tested

2023-2025

test
years

Key performance

Overall rating: 94.9% (59 measurements from 5 independent tests)
The overall rating is calculated as the arithmetic average of the average scores for each discipline, to eliminate bias towards disciplines with a large number of tests.

Dry Performance

  • Dry braking

    (5/5)
    Elite
    Based on 5 tests|1 wins|Avg. pos. 2.6th|1-5th range|Rating: 98.4%
    Performance Chart
    • Good: 4 (80%) i A solid performance, clearly above the average.
    • Average: 1 (20%) i A typical result, close to the test average.
    Detailed Test Results: 5 tests analyzed (2023-2025)
    Key statistics
    • Typically outperforms 82.8% of competitors per test
    • 🏆 Victories (1st place): 1 of 5
    • ✅ Podium finishes (TOP-3): 4 of 5
    • ✅ No bottom-half finishes
    • ✅ No worst-3 finishes
    • ✅ No last-place finishes
    Results in numbers
    • Best result:41.4 m (2023 Auto Bild SUV)
    • Worst result:43.5 m (2024 AUTO Straßenverkehr)
    • Average result:42.3 m
    • Typical gap to leader:+0.29 – +1.4 m
    • Max gap to leader:+2.2 m (2025 Auto Bild Sportscars)
  • Dry handling

    (2/5)
    Poor
    Based on 5 tests|1 wins|Avg. pos. 6.4th|1-10th range|Rating: 98.7%
    Performance Chart
    • Good: 1 (20%) i A solid performance, clearly above the average.
    • Average: 1 (20%) i A typical result, close to the test average.
    • Weak: 1 (20%) i The result is noticeably below the average.
    • Poor: 2 (40%) i A poor result, significantly worse than the test average.
    Detailed Test Results: 5 tests analyzed (2023-2025)
    Key statistics
    • Typically outperforms 35.3% of competitors per test
    • 🏆 Victories (1st place): 1 of 5
    • ✅ Podium finishes (TOP-3): 1 of 5
    • ⚠️ Bottom-half finishes: 3 of 5
    • ⚠️ Worst-3 finishes: 3 of 5
    • ❌ Last-place finish: 2 of 5

Wet Performance

  • Wet braking

    (4/5)
    Good
    Based on 5 tests|1 wins|Avg. pos. 3th|1-7th range|Rating: 96.8%
    Performance Chart
    • Good: 3 (60%) i A solid performance, clearly above the average.
    • Average: 1 (20%) i A typical result, close to the test average.
    • Weak: 1 (20%) i The result is noticeably below the average.
    Detailed Test Results: 5 tests analyzed (2023-2025)
    Key statistics
    • Typically outperforms 74.1% of competitors per test
    • 🏆 Victories (1st place): 1 of 5
    • ✅ Podium finishes (TOP-3): 4 of 5
    • ⚠️ Bottom-half finishes: 1 of 5
    • ⚠️ Worst-3 finishes: 1 of 5
    • ✅ No last-place finishes
    Results in numbers
    • Best result:34 m (2023 AMS)
    • Worst result:49.8 m (2025 Auto Bild Sportscars)
    • Average result:39 m
    • Typical gap to leader:+1 – +2.14 m
    • Max gap to leader:+2.5 m (2025 Auto Bild Sportscars)
  • Wet handling

    (4/5)
    Good
    Based on 5 tests|2 wins|Avg. pos. 3.6th|1-6th range|Rating: 99.2%
    Performance Chart
    • Good: 2 (40%) i A solid performance, clearly above the average.
    • Average: 2 (40%) i A typical result, close to the test average.
    • Weak: 1 (20%) i The result is noticeably below the average.
    Detailed Test Results: 5 tests analyzed (2023-2025)
    Key statistics
    • Typically outperforms 66.7% of competitors per test
    • 🏆 Victories (1st place): 2 of 5
    • ✅ Podium finishes (TOP-3): 2 of 5
    • ⚠️ Bottom-half finishes: 2 of 5
    • ✅ No worst-3 finishes
    • ✅ No last-place finishes
  • Wet lateral handling

    (4.5/5)
    Exemplary
    Based on 3 tests|1 wins|Avg. pos. 3th|1-4th range|Rating: 99.1%
    Performance Chart
    • Good: 1 (33%) i A solid performance, clearly above the average.
    • Average: 2 (67%) i A typical result, close to the test average.
    Detailed Test Results: 3 tests analyzed (2023-2025)
    Key statistics
    • Typically outperforms 72.2% of competitors per test
    • 🏆 Victories (1st place): 1 of 3
    • ✅ Podium finishes (TOP-3): 1 of 3
    • ⚠️ Bottom-half finishes: 1 of 3
    • ✅ No worst-3 finishes
    • ✅ No last-place finishes

Aquaplaning resistance

  • Straight aqua

    (3/5)
    Average
    Based on 5 tests|0 wins|Avg. pos. 5th|2-6th range|Rating: 95.7%
    Performance Chart
    • Good: 1 (20%) i A solid performance, clearly above the average.
    • Average: 2 (40%) i A typical result, close to the test average.
    • Weak: 2 (40%) i The result is noticeably below the average.
    Detailed Test Results: 5 tests analyzed (2023-2025)
    Key statistics
    • Typically outperforms 49.5% of competitors per test
    • ➖ No first-place finishes
    • ✅ Podium finishes (TOP-3): 1 of 5
    • ⚠️ Bottom-half finishes: 3 of 5
    • ⚠️ Worst-3 finishes: 1 of 5
    • ✅ No last-place finishes
    Results in numbers
    • Best result:85.8 km/h (2023 Tyre Reviews SUV)
    • Worst result:73.9 km/h (2023 AMS)
    • Average result:79 km/h
    • Typical gap to leader:-5.2 – -2.2 km/h
    • Max gap to leader:-5.5 km/h (2023 Auto Bild SUV)
  • Lateral aqua

    (2/5)
    Poor
    Based on 4 tests|0 wins|Avg. pos. 7.3th|6-8th range|Rating: 76.4%
    Performance Chart
    • Average: 1 (25%) i A typical result, close to the test average.
    • Weak: 3 (75%) i The result is noticeably below the average.
    Detailed Test Results: 4 tests analyzed (2023-2025)
    Key statistics
    • Typically outperforms 23.1% of competitors per test
    • ➖ No first-place finishes
    • ➖ No TOP-3 finishes
    • ⚠️ Bottom-half finishes: 4 of 4
    • ⚠️ Worst-3 finishes: 2 of 4
    • ✅ No last-place finishes

Snow Performance

  • Snow braking

    (3/5)
    Average
    Based on 5 tests|0 wins|Avg. pos. 5.4th|4-7th range|Rating: 95%
    Performance Chart
    • Average: 5 (100%) i A typical result, close to the test average.
    Detailed Test Results: 5 tests analyzed (2023-2025)
    Key statistics
    • Typically outperforms 47.7% of competitors per test
    • ➖ No first-place finishes
    • ➖ No TOP-3 finishes
    • ⚠️ Bottom-half finishes: 4 of 5
    • ✅ No worst-3 finishes
    • ✅ No last-place finishes
    Results in numbers
    • Best result:16.23 m (2023 Tyre Reviews SUV)
    • Worst result:31.1 m (2025 Auto Bild Sportscars)
    • Average result:25.3 m
    • Typical gap to leader:+0.41 – +2.5 m
    • Max gap to leader:+3.2 m (2025 Auto Bild Sportscars)
  • Snow handling

    (4/5)
    Good
    Based on 5 tests|0 wins|Avg. pos. 4th|2-6th range|Rating: 97.6%
    Performance Chart
    • Good: 2 (40%) i A solid performance, clearly above the average.
    • Average: 3 (60%) i A typical result, close to the test average.
    Detailed Test Results: 5 tests analyzed (2023-2025)
    Key statistics
    • Typically outperforms 61.6% of competitors per test
    • ➖ No first-place finishes
    • ✅ Podium finishes (TOP-3): 2 of 5
    • ⚠️ Bottom-half finishes: 2 of 5
    • ✅ No worst-3 finishes
    • ✅ No last-place finishes
  • Snow lateral handling

    (4.5/5)
    Exemplary
    Based on 2 tests|1 wins|Avg. pos. 4th|1-7th range|Rating: 97.7%
    Performance Chart
    • Good: 1 (50%) i A solid performance, clearly above the average.
    • Average: 1 (50%) i A typical result, close to the test average.
    Detailed Test Results: 2 tests analyzed (2023)
    Key statistics
    • Typically outperforms 66.7% of competitors per test
    • 🏆 Victories (1st place): 1 of 2
    • ✅ Podium finishes (TOP-3): 1 of 2
    • ⚠️ Bottom-half finishes: 1 of 2
    • ✅ No worst-3 finishes
    • ✅ No last-place finishes
  • Snow traction

    (3.5/5)
    Good
    Based on 5 tests|0 wins|Avg. pos. 4.4th|2-8th range|Rating: 96.7%
    Performance Chart
    • Good: 3 (60%) i A solid performance, clearly above the average.
    • Average: 2 (40%) i A typical result, close to the test average.
    Detailed Test Results: 5 tests analyzed (2023-2025)
    Key statistics
    • Typically outperforms 61.3% of competitors per test
    • ➖ No first-place finishes
    • ✅ Podium finishes (TOP-3): 3 of 5
    • ⚠️ Bottom-half finishes: 2 of 5
    • ✅ No worst-3 finishes
    • ✅ No last-place finishes

Secondary

  • Rolling resistance

    (2/5)
    Poor
    Based on 5 tests|0 wins|Avg. pos. 7.2th|4-10th range|Rating: 83.5%
    Performance Chart
    • Average: 2 (40%) i A typical result, close to the test average.
    • Weak: 2 (40%) i The result is noticeably below the average.
    • Poor: 1 (20%) i A poor result, significantly worse than the test average.
    Detailed Test Results: 5 tests analyzed (2023-2025)
    Key statistics
    • Typically outperforms 28.1% of competitors per test
    • ➖ No first-place finishes
    • ➖ No TOP-3 finishes
    • ⚠️ Bottom-half finishes: 4 of 5
    • ⚠️ Worst-3 finishes: 3 of 5
    • ❌ Last-place finish: 1 of 5
    Results in numbers
    • Best result:7.63 kg/t (2023 Auto Bild SUV)
    • Worst result:8.7 kg/t (2024 AUTO Straßenverkehr)
    • Average result:8.2 kg/t
    • Typical gap to leader:+1.08 – +1.67 kg/t
    • Max gap to leader:+1.94 kg/t (2023 Tyre Reviews SUV)
  • Noise

    (4/5)
    Good
    Based on 5 tests|1 wins|Avg. pos. 3.2th|1-5th range|Rating: 98.7%
    Performance Chart
    • Good: 3 (60%) i A solid performance, clearly above the average.
    • Average: 2 (40%) i A typical result, close to the test average.
    Detailed Test Results: 5 tests analyzed (2023-2025)
    Key statistics
    • Typically outperforms 70.8% of competitors per test
    • 🏆 Victories (1st place): 1 of 5
    • ✅ Podium finishes (TOP-3): 3 of 5
    • ⚠️ Bottom-half finishes: 1 of 5
    • ✅ No worst-3 finishes
    • ✅ No last-place finishes
    Results in numbers
    • Best result:70 dB (2023 Tyre Reviews SUV)
    • Worst result:73.1 dB (2023 Auto Bild SUV)
    • Average result:71.9 dB
    • Typical gap to leader:+0.95 – +1.35 dB
    • Max gap to leader:+1.5 dB (2023 AMS)

Pirelli Scorpion Winter 2 Test History

Independent magazines and organizations have tested the tire in various sizes multiple times. The detailed results from each test are below.

Year
Magazine
Size
Place
Score
2025
Auto Bild Sportscars
235/50 R19
4 (11)
2024
AUTO Straßenverkehr
235/55 R18
4 (10)
2023
Auto Bild SUV
225/60 R18
3 (10)
2023
AMS
255/45 R20
5 (7)
Very Good
2023
Tyre Reviews SUV
235/60 R18
6 (9)
Recommended

Pirelli Scorpion Winter 2 vs. Competitors

Key Statistics

  • Dry braking #2 of 11
  • ⚠️ Dry handling #9 of 10
  • Wet braking #3 of 11
  • Wet handling #3 of 10
  • ⚠️ Straight aqua #8 of 11
  • ⚠️ Snow braking #8 of 11
  • Snow handling #5 of 10
  • Snow traction #4 of 10
  • Noise #3 of 11
  • ⚠️ Rolling resistance #10 of 11
#
Model
Performance ⓘ
% ⓘ
Abs. ⓘ
1
99.22%
0.8%
-0.32 m
2
Pirelli Scorpion Winter 2
98.41%
3
97.67%
0.7%
+0.29 m
4
97.53%
0.9%
+0.35 m
5
96.15%
2.3%
+0.90 m
6
95.78%
2.6%
+1.05 m
7
95.70%
2.7%
+1.08 m
8
95.55%
2.9%
+1.14 m
9
95.19%
3.2%
+1.29 m
10
94.70%
3.7%
+1.48 m
11
92.91%
5.5%
+2.20 m
#
Model
Performance ⓘ
% ⓘ
Abs. ⓘ
1
99.59%
0.8%
+0.84 km/h
2
99.40%
0.7%
+0.66 km/h
3
99.34%
0.6%
+0.60 km/h
4
99.31%
0.6%
+0.57 km/h
5
99.16%
0.4%
+0.41 km/h
6
99.05%
0.3%
+0.30 km/h
7
98.87%
0.1%
+0.13 km/h
8
98.79%
0.0%
+0.05 km/h
9
Pirelli Scorpion Winter 2
98.74%
10
98.57%
0.2%
-0.17 km/h
#
Model
Performance ⓘ
% ⓘ
Abs. ⓘ
1
99.57%
2.8%
-1.38 m
2
97.74%
0.9%
-0.47 m
3
Pirelli Scorpion Winter 2
96.80%
4
95.48%
1.3%
+0.66 m
5
95.30%
1.5%
+0.75 m
6
95.12%
1.7%
+0.84 m
7
94.04%
2.8%
+1.38 m
8
93.84%
3.0%
+1.48 m
9
93.76%
3.0%
+1.52 m
10
91.33%
5.5%
+2.74 m
11
89.22%
7.6%
+3.79 m
#
Model
Performance ⓘ
% ⓘ
Abs. ⓘ
1
99.62%
0.5%
+0.37 km/h
2
99.50%
0.3%
+0.28 km/h
3
Pirelli Scorpion Winter 2
99.16%
4
99.04%
0.1%
-0.09 km/h
5
98.74%
0.4%
-0.34 km/h
6
98.53%
0.6%
-0.50 km/h
7
98.45%
0.7%
-0.57 km/h
8
98.09%
1.1%
-0.85 km/h
9
97.70%
1.5%
-1.17 km/h
10
97.61%
1.5%
-1.24 km/h
#
Model
Performance ⓘ
% ⓘ
Abs. ⓘ
1
100.00%
4.3%
+3.47 km/h
2
99.75%
4.1%
+3.27 km/h
3
98.84%
3.2%
+2.55 km/h
4
98.50%
2.8%
+2.27 km/h
5
96.39%
0.7%
+0.59 km/h
6
95.99%
0.3%
+0.27 km/h
7
95.72%
0.1%
+0.05 km/h
8
Pirelli Scorpion Winter 2
95.66%
9
95.37%
0.3%
-0.24 km/h
10
95.17%
0.5%
-0.39 km/h
11
95.13%
0.5%
-0.43 km/h
#
Model
Performance ⓘ
% ⓘ
Abs. ⓘ
1
98.58%
3.6%
2
97.18%
2.2%
3
97.07%
2.0%
4
96.91%
1.9%
5
96.10%
1.1%
6
95.99%
1.0%
7
95.81%
0.8%
8
Pirelli Scorpion Winter 2
95.02%
9
95.01%
0.0%
10
92.71%
2.3%
11
87.79%
7.2%
#
Model
Performance ⓘ
% ⓘ
Abs. ⓘ
1
99.48%
1.9%
2
98.02%
0.4%
3
97.76%
0.1%
4
97.67%
0.0%
5
Pirelli Scorpion Winter 2
97.63%
6
96.29%
1.3%
7
95.89%
1.7%
8
95.89%
1.7%
9
95.25%
2.4%
10
93.70%
3.9%
#
Model
Performance ⓘ
% ⓘ
Abs. ⓘ
1
99.98%
3.3%
2
98.65%
1.9%
3
96.97%
0.2%
4
Pirelli Scorpion Winter 2
96.72%
5
95.98%
0.7%
6
95.53%
1.2%
7
95.46%
1.3%
8
94.57%
2.2%
9
91.28%
5.4%
10
88.12%
8.6%
#
Model
Performance ⓘ
% ⓘ
Abs. ⓘ
1
100.00%
1.3%
-0.92 dB
2
99.15%
0.4%
-0.31 dB
3
Pirelli Scorpion Winter 2
98.72%
4
98.69%
0.0%
+0.03 dB
5
98.49%
0.2%
+0.17 dB
6
98.35%
0.4%
+0.27 dB
7
97.88%
0.8%
+0.61 dB
8
97.65%
1.1%
+0.78 dB
9
96.84%
1.9%
+1.36 dB
10
96.38%
2.3%
+1.69 dB
11
95.33%
3.4%
+2.44 dB
#
Model
Performance ⓘ
% ⓘ
Abs. ⓘ
1
97.69%
14.2%
-1.02 kg/t
2
95.75%
12.3%
-0.89 kg/t
3
91.61%
8.2%
-0.59 kg/t
4
88.30%
4.8%
-0.35 kg/t
5
88.04%
4.6%
-0.33 kg/t
6
87.20%
3.7%
-0.27 kg/t
7
86.03%
2.6%
-0.19 kg/t
8
84.17%
0.7%
-0.05 kg/t
9
83.82%
0.4%
-0.03 kg/t
10
Pirelli Scorpion Winter 2
83.46%
11
77.54%
5.9%
+0.43 kg/t

alltyretests
AllTyreTests.com
Add a comment